In the Mike Shanahan era, the Broncos are 27 wins and 10 losses in second match-ups (in 9 seasons)... And a perfect 3-0 in second match-ups that happen in the post season.
After first meeting wins, the Broncos are 16 and 5 in the second game, completely dominating the rematch. After first meeting losses, the Broncos are 11 and 5 in the second game.
Since John Elway retired, the Broncos still haven't lost a beat in this area of second match-ups... Since 2000, the Broncos are 10 and 4 in seasonal rematches.
And in the Jake Plummer era, the Broncos currently sit at a perfect 3-0 record on the rematch. What's more, the Broncos have won by an average of 20.8 points in Plummer rematches.